Walt Whitman
Meltzer, Milton. 2002. Walt
Whitman: A biography.
Brookfield, CT: Twenty-First Century
Books. ISBN: 0761322728.
This young adult biography by Milton Meltzer focuses as much on its
subject's politics as his writing, for which Walt Whitman is most
remembered. Meltzer begins with Whitman's birth and takes the
reader step-by-step through the course of his life. Along the
way, the author intersperses poetry written by Whitman that illustrates
his feelings, motivations for his actions, and the way he lived his
life. For example, after writing about Whitman's disgust at the
gap between rich and poor, Meltzer includes lines from "Song of Myself"
that tell Whitman's feelings in his own words:
"Many
sweating, ploughing, thrashing, and then the chaff for payment
receiving,
A few idly
owning, and they the wheat continually claiming." (Meltzer, p.67)
This technique gives the reader valuable background information which
makes Whitman's words more meaningful, and also seems to turn Whitman's
poems into even more of an autobiography.
Meltzer writes in a conversational style that speaks directly to the
reader, such as "You can see it in LEAVES where he wrote these
lines..." (Meltzer, p.12), "How do you write a poem? Is it the
inspiration
of the moment?" (Meltzer, p.78), and "We know how widely he read, and
his
notebooks show he was responding to the power of the poets."
(Meltzer, p.78) Meltzer's tone suggests that he and the reader,
together,
are fleshing out Whitman's innermost thought and motivations.
Meltzer further earns credibility with young adult readers by revealing
some of Whitman's faults that are shocking in today's society, such as
rumors of Whitman's affair with a young boy (Meltzer, p.42) and his
strong
racist feelings (Meltzer, p.125). Meltzer also explains
differences
between modern times and Whitman's society in terms that today's young
person can understand, such as "Why would people in great numbers turn
out to hear someone make a speech? The reason is plain: It
was entertainment. Recall that there were few other ways to be
diverted from your work and your worries. Radio, television,
moves were in the distant future. So were such sports as
basketball and football that today draw vast crowds." (Meltzer,
p.75)
Black and white photos of Whitman, his family and surroundings as well
as copies of some of his original manuscripts illustrate this
biography. Although sources are not directly noted in the text,
the author includes a timeline of Whitman's life, a section on further
reading, and an index. His conversation with his reader continues
in these access features as Meltzer writes "For those who have access
to the Internet, searching for Walt Whitman with any good search engine
will lead to many sites. Please remember that all sites are
sources needing to be checked, evaluated, and compared with other
sources." (Meltzer, p.155)
In her review in Horn Book Magazine,
Burns writes "As indicated in a
short foreword, Meltzer's presentation of Whitman's life is
interpretive rather than simply a portrait of the man in the many
stages of his life, which, on the whole, was quite ordinary." She
goes on to say at another point in the review, "In her Walt Whitman,
Catherine Reef offers a more intimate view, a glimpse into Whitman's
daily life rather than an analysis of his politics; taken together, the
two biographies offer greater insight into Whitman's work than would
each alone." This is certainly not an exhaustive work on Whitman,
but it gives a unique glimpse into his life, the times in which he
lived, and how these two things directly affected his writings.
Burns, Mary M. 2002. Walt Whitman (Book). Horn Book Magazine 78(5). In
EBSCOHost (database online). Available
from http://search.epnet.com/login.asp. Accessed 08 February
2005.
Back to Module 2: Criteria for Nonfiction
|